News Many voters say they’re OK with a gay president, but America isn’t. I don’t buy it. November 23, 2019 Suzette Hackney, Indianapolis Star Comments Off on Many voters say they’re OK with a gay president, but America isn’t. I don’t buy it. It's an interesting if puzzling dichotomy: Some voters say they would not penalize Pete Buttigieg for being gay — but are fearful others would.